Upselling or Bait and switch?
Printed From: Carpet Cleaning Forum
Category: Carpet Cleaners Discussion
Forum Name: Carpet Cleaners Hangout
Forum Description: General discussion on anything related to carpet cleaning
URL: https://www.kleenkuip.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=589
Printed Date: 23/February/2025 at 11:07am Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.06 - https://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Upselling or Bait and switch?
Posted By: Superglide Ken
Subject: Upselling or Bait and switch?
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 1:44pm
In the carpet cleaning business there are 2 general ways for pricing your service. The first way is called full value pricing. Here you calculate what it costs to provide the service, add on your desired margin plus retirement costs and equipment replacement costs and you are there. This resulted in a price that your customer knew up front before you started the job. Many of the services to complete the job were all inclusive in the price. This is how it is still done in many of the smaller centers of the USA and Canada. It works there, because competition in small towns is low, and price chopping is rare.
In recent years another system has grown to be dominant in many of the larger centers. That is loss leader selling. Here the service is offered below the true cost of providing it , in the advertised price. An example of this would be where 2 rooms get cleaned for $49. The real costs may me $80 or more , but the company is relying on the cleaner to sell the customer additional services while in the home to make up the difference on the loss suffered on the base special. Sometimes this is carried too far, and high pressure sales tactics are used to sell uneducated customers services they don't want ot need. If you advertise a service for less than it costs you, and jam other services to the customer regardless of need, is this ethical?
How do we change this? Or is this way alright with you?
------------- Inventor of the Teflon Wand Glide and the Turboteck Rotary Air Duct Cleaners for TMs.
|
Replies:
Posted By: Joel
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 1:59pm
How about the supermarkets selling milk at below cost to get you in there and shaft the corner stores.
How about buying a pair of glasses and get the second free? Of course you need the anti glare and scratch resist.
Thats the way of the world.
|
Posted By: Superglide Ken
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 2:25pm
Joel wrote" That is the way of the World"
Getting the shaft?????? Or buying milk below cost?lol. In the selling of goods, this has been done a long time, because that is a commodity and competitive selling produces that result on apples sold against apples. A service is different, and varies in quality from provider to provider. We can teach the customer that our service is valuable or it is not. I used to price my service at .10/sq ft back in 1996, but now get .50/sq ft for it. What has changed? Me! I woke up to the fact that the only one that stopped me from charging more was my perception of what my service was worth. Once I beleived that, I could make my customers believe it too. I now have the highest cleaning prices in Calgary, and have for 3 years now.In case you think that some boom in the Calgary economy made this happen, I will tell you that the average price charged in Calgary for furnished residential carpet cleaning is still no higher than .20/sq ft charged by my would be competiors.But in my price bracket, I have no competitors! It only took me 5 years to 5X my price to where I am now. I fired alot of customers that did not agree with me, but now have ones that pay my price. It can be done.
------------- Inventor of the Teflon Wand Glide and the Turboteck Rotary Air Duct Cleaners for TMs.
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 3:41pm
Ken: Lets tale about the supermarket and milk. Where is the milk? It is at the back of the store where you havew to walk by everyhting else to get there right? Beside the milk will be bread or somehhnig priced around normal, something you probably don't need but will buy while you are there. Same with Coke & Pepsi on sale with a stack of potato chips pleed beside them. Convience Stores are just that. If you want to buy more than you have there you deserve to pay twice what you would at a supermarket.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 3:43pm
What a lot of customers do is... "fail to read the ads properly" there is no such thing as a bait and switch if you read the ad.
read read
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 3:47pm
Mr. Steamer: If the printing on the disclaimer was as large as the ad. Do you think anyone would call?data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 3:55pm
the size of the ad cost money... you want the most important things to be up front..
it doesn't matter they would still call... they don't trust small companies like yours doug...
In the gta you'd be out of business already douggie boy
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 4:06pm
Mr. Steamer: being in the GTA and the little service you have to apply to stay in business You are a joke. We have had many so called super service companies come from the city. They are glad to get back to the city where nobody remembers the a**holes who cleaned their place last year! data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: Superglide Ken
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 4:14pm
Good discussion boys. Hopefully a few others will join in too with their input.
------------- Inventor of the Teflon Wand Glide and the Turboteck Rotary Air Duct Cleaners for TMs.
|
Posted By: splash_$$$_dash
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 5:16pm
"I always get the old ladies on the stain gard" This is the stuff my "friends" who do upsell talk about ALL THE TIME. Nothing to do with reading the ad. these guys brag about their upselling and ripping people off with charging tons for gard or deodorizer.
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 5:18pm
Mr. Steamer: You are probably right. There is a commerical that used to be on TV I think FRAM used to run it. " You can pay me know or pay me later" I like that add. I don't use those words because I don't think they would be apprioate in someone's home. But our comapny has ethics and we backup all our statements. Weather it is an insurance claim or a simple carpet cleaning job. It is done our way or get someone else. If I am guaranteeing the job it is done my way. Unfortunately we are not Wendy's the job is not done you way it's done our way to your satisfaction. Let me tell you something else Steamer. In a small area like where I live in not everyone from the city could handle the fact in this small area you can run but you can't hide. People call at all hours to ask questions, people stop you on the street, when you are out for a special dinner it dosen't matter to them. My wife even gets asked at the grocery store how do you get this out. People will try to book you when you meet them on the street. Life is different in a small to wn. You have no set hours because if they want you they will find you.
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: splash_$$$_dash
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 6:24pm
Damn I'm glad I don't live in a small redneck town like that.
Man in good old rude Toronto if they stop you.....you just give them a hard stare and say fukc off lady can't you see I'm trying to chow down with my wife and kids.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c0ae/7c0ae26cce6710c9beb950fcaeaf459a37098aa9" alt=""
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 9:40pm
Thats what I'm talking about doug... you are the big name in your town.. everyone else is small fry... you have cornered the market.. how can anyone else compete??? A Customers wants the same company the same Tech, the same everything as they got last time...
and thats our good ol boy dougdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c0ae/7c0ae26cce6710c9beb950fcaeaf459a37098aa9" alt=""
in a small town thats the way it should be.... but the GTA is big it's hard to corner the whole market
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 9:54pm
Mr. Steamer: If I had all the market covered I would need two horses.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 19/September/2004 at 10:02pm
Posted By: greg
Date Posted: 20/September/2004 at 7:32pm
the price we give on the phone is for cleaning. other services we provide while in the home are extra fabicgarding, pet oder removeal etc .but the client is alwas told before we start what the total cost will be.
------------- nothing is impossable. it just hasn't been done yet.
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 7:24am
Ads around here read like:
(in bold) ONLY $XX per ROOM!!!
(fine print) subject to site inspection, customer to pre-vacuum and
move required funiture, minimum 3 rooms, price does not include GST,
maximum room size 12 sq metres, extra costs may apply for light
coloured carpet, wool carpets, heavily soiled carpet and pet hair.
Price does not include removal of spots or stains.
The customers are sick of this stuff. I pre-quote and give a firm written price to do the job they expect.
-Allen
|
Posted By: Superglide Ken
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 1:15pm
Well, that add sure nailed down the price, didn't it? lol
------------- Inventor of the Teflon Wand Glide and the Turboteck Rotary Air Duct Cleaners for TMs.
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 2:07pm
Allen: Mr. Surround Sound that looks like the standard big company ad. Similar to the ones I am accoustume to. People may be sick of them. But the same ones keep applying their price shopping mentality to these companies and hireing them. The will all say the samething . We will never get sucked in by that ad again. But guess what in a year or two guess who their best customers are? It's called monetary weekness.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 4:55pm
surroundings wrote:
Ads around here read like:
(in bold) ONLY $XX per ROOM!!!
(fine print) subject to site inspection, customer to pre-vacuum and move required furniture, minimum 3 rooms, price does not include GIST, maximum room size 12 sq MITREs, extra costs may apply for light coloured carpet, wool carpets, heavily soiled carpet and pet hair. Price does not include removal of spots or stains.
The customers are sick of this stuff. I pre-quote and give a firm written price to do the job they expect.
-Allen
| man you people don't think... you have to put this stuff in your ad., because it does cost more... but imagine if you put all this info in big bold print....
number 1 it would cost a fortune to print... the size of the add would have to be huge
number 2 it would be too much info and you'd loose your focal point (the thing your trying to sell)
no one needs to see all the extras in big bold print... and once it's on the flyer that IS NOT BAIT AND SWITCH
it's you little guys(like myself) that put out an ad with your price $5 bucks a room, and when you get to the customers house it's a whole different story...
I've even heard of companies out here asking for money up front..
so before y'all start posting lets understand what exactly is bait and switch
|
Posted By: doug
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 6:14pm
Allen's been cleaning all summer just trien to raise a dollar
Sometimes I wonder just how their goen to do it
Clean 3 rooms and a hall for just under a dollar
Sometimes I wonder just what I am going to do because there ain't no cure for the bait and switch bluesdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dc8c/1dc8cf661c3e235378022ed51a0f12fce5a2ea9c" alt="Guitar"
------------- Just My opinion
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 8:15pm
Mr. Steamer,
You're right. I don't think. But why would I put that fine
print in bold on my ad? My cost includes moving furniture.
It includes GST (Goods and Services Tax ... 10% here in
Australia). I do NOT have a minimum # of rooms, I quote by the
square metre of the area I clean, I expect that I will have a heavily
soiled creme wool carpet. (It does not take THAT much longer to
clean! Really!) Very few stains require an oxidisation treatment,
or a heat transfer... and those that may, I point out during my
quote. If the stain does not come out during regular cleaning,
I'll hit it with a NVDS or a neutral spotter... whatever it takes...let
it sit for a while, then extract again.
I'm silly enough to quote on a job well done, and include the service
of moving funiture, the service of pre-vac, the service of
extracting heavily soiled carpets. Now that's SERVICE SERVICE
SERVICE, ain't it?
The above ad basically reads as a set price for traffic areas only on a not-too-dirty dark carpet. Gimmie a break here...
-Allen
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 8:35pm
doug wrote:
Clean 3 rooms and a hall for just under a dollar
|
Three rooms and a hall? Did one like this yesterday. Lady
responded to my 'Fourth Room Free' ad: dining room- 11.9 sq m. living
room- 22.44 sq. m. master b/room 19.76 sq. m.( traffic lanes only...
BIG master b/room!) hall- 7.72 sq m.
The hall was free. Normal cost would have been $278.23... with
the 'special' the cost was $243.95. That's $4.50 per sq. metre for
those of you not into the 'math' of it.
Make-Up in the master, dog hair everywhere, red wine spill in the
dining. The only thing that took extra time was the
make-up. Used a citrus solvent on the little spots. Hall
and living were a dark green, master and dining were a peach colour.
Also did 2 entry mats at no cost.
Total time of 3 hours, inluding set-up... moving AND replacing
furniture, pre-vac... post rake. They didn't go with the carpet
protection. The Mrs. made me a coffee, and the Mr. gave me a
bottle of homebrew beer when he found out I dabbled in this field
myself.
I love my job,
Allen
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 9:23pm
Just to make the dollar conversion easier:
1.00 CANADIAN DOLLAR (CAD) = 1.1042 AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR (AUD)
That is according to the http://www.bloomberg.com/analysis/calculators/currency.html#results - Bloomberg Currency Calculator
Let's put that into perspective, shall we? In Australia today,
2 litres of Coke is avaliable on special for $1.65
A three year fixed home loan rate is 6.5 % per annum.
A Quarter Pounder Value Meal is $5.25
Diesel fuel is $1.13 per litre (that's $4.28 per gallon)
and a brand new Hyundai 7L V6 Tiburon is $31,990
ChemDry charge $25 per room with a 3 room minimum and other fine print.
Surroundings charge $4.50 per square metre for carpet cleaning.... with no fne print.
How does that stack up with you guys?
-Allen
|
Posted By: Superglide Ken
Date Posted: 21/September/2004 at 10:42pm
You guys take a hosing on everything but the Chemry guy. They charge more over here.
------------- Inventor of the Teflon Wand Glide and the Turboteck Rotary Air Duct Cleaners for TMs.
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 22/September/2004 at 12:42am
surroundings wrote:
Mr. Steamer,
You're right. I don't think. But why would I put that fine print in bold on my ad? My cost includes moving furniture. It includes GST (Goods and Services Tax ... 10% here in Australia). I do NOT have a minimum # of rooms, I quote by the square metre of the area I clean, I expect that I will have a heavily soiled creme wool carpet. (It does not take THAT much longer to clean! Really!) Very few stains require an oxidisation treatment, or a heat transfer... and those that may, I point out during my quote. If the stain does not come out during regular cleaning, I'll hit it with a NVDS or a neutral spotter... whatever it takes...let it sit for a while, then extract again.
I'm silly enough to quote on a job well done, and include the service of moving funiture, the service of pre-vac, the service of extracting heavily soiled carpets. Now that's SERVICE SERVICE SERVICE, ain't it?
The above ad basically reads as a set price for traffic areas only on a not-too-dirty dark carpet. Gimmie a break here...
-Allen
| Well said Allen thats just my point.... you are dealing with small volume running a mom and pops carpet cleaning out fit... do a lot of in home est. You may get 5 or maybe even 10 calls a day.... The real big guy doesn't have time to do what you do.... he gets maybe 300 calls a day...
As a big outfit you have to put everything on the ad or its called a bait and switch.... EVERYTHING
The time it takes to do a in-home you could have cleaned that customer and been on the way to the next...oh I forgot you only do 1 or so a day so take your time...
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 22/September/2004 at 2:47am
I'm still not attracted to an advertised cost that is rarely (if ever)
adhered to. Yes, the customer should read the fine print.
Buyer Beware.
If it sounds too good to be true, it probabally is.
There's one born every minute.
I'm not comfortable with that for our little 'Mom & Pop' Pty
Ltd. I'm too stinkin' proud I suppose. Pride makes me want
to hold my head up high and meet last month's customer's eye at
the grocery store. Pride makes me wanna be known as
'expensive.... but worth it' Sure, pride is one of the seven
deadly sins, but if I'm gonna go to hell 'cause I take pride in what I
do, then so be it.
I think that customers are better educated now then ever before.
It may only be a matter of time before the 'cheap & nasty'
operators start a 'VIP' or 'Executive' level of carpet cleaning.
Until then, I'm IT (around these parts anyway).
Cheers!
-Allen
ps: we PREFER 'boutique' over 'mom and pop'
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 22/September/2004 at 6:45am
boutique ...I like it.... kinda feminine though...lol I would rather Haberdashery ...no offense with the mom & pop thing I was just trying to get my point accross
|
Posted By: surroundings
Date Posted: 22/September/2004 at 4:00pm
You got your point across. Now that I know where you're coming from, I can't disagree.
On the point of the bigger places trying to offer better quality:
Mrs. Surround Sound just made mention that over here, McDonalds has
just started converting many of their stores to McCafe, which serves
better coffee, high quality pastries, fresh blended juice, and
healthier fresh sandwiches.
Just like some of the Mom & Pop cafes.
Is that so in Canada as well?
-Allen
|
Posted By: MR. STEAMER
Date Posted: 22/September/2004 at 7:48pm
See they can try to copy a mom and pop... but there is one problem they have to hire... and employees don't care
mom and pop will always have better service
|
|